Storm King on the Hudson

Samuel Colman, Storm King on the Hudson, 1866, oil on canvas, Smithsonian American Art Museum, Gift of John Gellatly, 1929.6.20
Creative Commons Zero license

The Hudson River was a beloved subject for American landscape painters, and this particular site was popular with artists in part due to the dramatic storms that gathered along the ridge of Storm King Mountain. By 1866, the river had become a major commercial route for trade as well as tourism, providing stone and other materials needed to build a rapidly expanding New York City further south. This was the point where the major water routes from the north met the railhead for the trains heading south, and commodities were offloaded from ships and onto trains. Samuel Colman painted both small sailboats and larger steam-powered tourist launches and freight boats, focusing on the changes taking place in commerce and leisure activities on the river. The painter’s nod to the transition from sail to steam interjects a modern note about progress in a classic landscape.

Artist

Samuel Colman

Date

1866

Location

Dimensions

32 ¹⁄₈ x 59 ⁷⁄₈ in. (81.6 x 152.0 cm.)

Credit Line

Smithsonian American Art Museum

Gift of John Gellatly

Mediums

oil

Mediums Description

oil on canvas

Classifications

Painting

Keywords

Figure group
Architecture – boat – riverboat
Landscape – mountain – Storm King
Landscape – river – Hudson River
Architecture – boat – rowboat

Object Number

1929.6.20

Palette

Emoji

Linked Open Data

Linked Open Data URI

Videos

Date

February 3, 2014

Information
Transcript

Smithsonian American Art Museum Director Elizabeth Broun shares her thoughts about personal favorites from the museum collection. Learn more about Storm King on the Hudson by Samuel Colman.

BETSY BROUN: Kay Larsen, art critic for New York Magazine, wrote about this 1866 painting of “Storm King on the Hudson” by Samuel Colman. She said it “marks the moment when paradise was invaded by men of commerce. Painters were left with a problem: what to do about the tanning factories, sawmills, paper factories, and the other small businesses that started to overtake the epic waterfalls and elegant forests along the Hudson.” The debates we still have today about competing claims of preservation and development were already major issues in the mid-nineteenth century. Samuel Colman gave equal time to both sides of the discussion by dividing his painting neatly into halves.

The protagonist of the right half is the mountain that was known to many as “Butter Hill” because of its soft, rounded shape. Today, we call it “Storm King Mountain”, a tribute to the frequent dark clouds that shroud its top. Colman gives nearly a third of the height of his canvas to these impressive clouds. Below the mountain is a vision of olden days, just passing into history about the time of the Civil War. Small boats hug the shore, and in the foreground, three men fish with nets. It’s clearly a family or local enterprise.

The left half represents the industrialized future. Giant commercial barges are linked together, their huge paddle wheels turned by coal-generated steam. Smoke stacks are at the center of this half of the composition, a threatening industrial parallel to the dark clouds over Storm King Mountain. The barges seem to bare down menacingly on the small fishing craft.

The two halves, we realize, are tenuously linked underwater by the fragile nets of the fishermen. It is as if Colman already knew that the uneasy coexistence of these two ways of life in his own present would soon be severed into two very different worlds: past and future. By carefully arranging his picture as a double square, Colman keeps the debate about industry and nature in balance. Are the barges symbols of promise and progress? Or are they destroyers?